Skip to content


Station Closures, Budget Cuts, Staffing Cuts…and the Race Card

1 comment

Firefighters have been saying it for years…you cannot cut staffing, close stations, and slash the budgets in public safety and think that nothing will change.

But no one seems to be listening.

Who cares? Other than us and the ones affected the answer is not to many other people.

We are out of sight and out of mind.

But who really gets shafted? I wrote about one such situation in Cape Coral, Florida surrounding brownouts here.

Patrick Mahoney (an author on FireGeezer.com) writes:

No matter what it is, when it comes to fire and police layoffs it’s nothing short of depriving the poor of what may be their only safety net in order to line the pockets of the rich and powerful. Departments in these situations need to get with their minority communities and explain the consequences (hint: nearly any fire department facing layoffs is in this situation because this sort of reverse Robin Hooding is rampant). There are a ton of civil rights groups, ministers’ alliances, and neighborhood associations that are more than happy to apply pressure to the cretins in local government. Read the entire article here

He is not alone…

Alan W. Silberberg writes:

So we have reached a critical decision point in the United States. Are we going to sacrifice our quality of life, our public safety over politically charged budget cutting, or are we going to create ways to fix the budget problems, and keep our lives safe? Read teh entire article here

Silberberg’s article is a well written piece meant to get people to their feet. To educate them that cuts to public safety can effect anyone and everyone. That public safety cuts are not the answer and that cuts MUST be made elsewhere!

Mahnoney’s article is meant to get firefighters to stand up. To educate the poorer communities that public safety cuts show that their governement does not care about them if they are willing to cut their services.

Both articles are worth the read….both are thought provoking…and both should get people thinking!

It Happened Again…Brownouts Blamed in Delayed Response during Medical Emergency

1 comment

It took around 2 years for the Cape Coral Fire Department (Florida) to learn a very costly lesson about brownouts.

Last week, the brownouts are being blamed for a delayed response in a fatal heart attack call. The closest rescue truck was out of service due to a brownout.

Firefighters don’t need to look any further for proof that brownouts don’t make sense and are unfair and unsafe for citizens.

As a firefighter, I really want to say “We told you so”, but that isn’t professional. Indeed, firefighters have been pointing to brownouts being unfair and unsafe for citizens, but in this case it might have cost someone their life.

At this point, the family is not making an issue of the response time according to the report. However, we all know how that can change when lawyers get involved.

Trucks, even entire fire stations in some fire districts, go unmanned for a shift when there are not enough people on duty to cover them. These brownouts save money by eliminating the need to pay overtime to fully staff the service. source news-press.com

I must say that I hope Cape Coral has learned their lesson and that they don’t have to settle with a huge settlement with the family.

I also hope that other localities learn from Cape Coral’s lesson and they decide to brownout or cut other things before the fire department.

I sincerely commend Cape Coral’s Mayor John Sullivan for correcting this issue!

You can read the entire report here.

Visit the Cape Coral Fire Department online here

Hat tip to The Secret List for this article

Fire Service Limbo

4 comments

As the “economy” continues to wane, the fire service continues to be bashed by poor leadership and one sided statistics which show room for more cuts.

Some say the economy is on an upturn. I am not an economist.

Fire Departments are not a new casualty to money issues. Actually, Fire Departments were being cut long before the economy went south. The FD’s were an easy target by politicians for downsizing when their special interest programs needed funding. Simply cut the FD’s and use the “new” money to fund their special pet projects. Once one person did it and got away with it, everyone else saddled up. The continual cuts to FD’s became an issue that firefighters kept raising their eyebrow to.

When the economy took the downturn, the FD’s continued to become the whipping post for budget cuts. Now more than ever, the politicians have been able to sell their downsizing ideas to the public. What the public isn’t shown is how the FD’s have been continually cut since way before the economy turned.

It is a simple sell to the public. We don’t want to increase your taxes so we have to make these cuts. People eat that up. They don’t want to pay more taxes.

That is where the Fire Service Limbo comes in. Just how low can we go?

Let us look at it this way…

Take the 80′s at the end of “America Burning”. FD’s were fully staffed, in service, and well fed. We had what we needed and didn’t ask for much. We ran emergencies. False alarms existed, but were usually handled if possible to curb future false calls.

By the 90′s, most City FD’s had merged with their EMS counterparts. The intent was good, most department merges were not handled ideally though. In the end, some departments still suffer the effects of poor merge practices/planning. Soon after, management realized that we had many more personnel and could cross-train Fire/EMS to create all in one employees.

By the end of the 90′s, we had trimmed the “fat” of the departments. We closed down engine companies and ladder companies because we can utilize the firefighter/EMT’s on the ambulances as the contingent of firefighters on scene of fire calls. We still have the same number of firefighters on calls, just not the same makeup of apparatus on those calls.

By 2000, we saw the need to continue twisting statistics. FD’s cut the amount of apparatus on responses, cut firefighters on rigs, cut more engine companies. Raises became intermittent, benefits became huge bargaining chips, health insurance premiums steadily increased. The Fire Service became younger, the training became harder to get on duty. Firefighters who were once hired to become firefighter/EMT’s were now hired to become Firefighter/ALS (paramedics and EMT-Intermediate). Fire calls increased, EMS calls increased.

Which brings us to now. We have seen administration positions continue to increase to help with all the bean counting, regulations, and pet projects. Much like private business, managers increase the amount of subordinates to make their jobs easier. FD’s see brownouts, closures, and lay offs. Firefighters see increased insurance premiums, lost benefits, loss of annual raises, loss of merit raises, loss of longevity raises, loss of overtime, fewer firefighters on rigs, fewer firefighters on scene, longer response times, waiting longer to get enough firefighters on scene, decreasing morale, less training, more regulations.

That is just a snapshot of what I see as the economical/management crippling of the fire service. This goes for EMS too. I realize that all of us may not be affected by all of these situations and others may see worse.

The limbo continues. It is only a matter of time before we will find ourselves laying flat on our back.

Rolling Brownouts, Firehouse Roulette, Firehouse Closures, Layoffs…

2 comments

Call it what you will, but I call it poor management.

The three highest priorities in any jurisdiction should be:

  • Public Safety
  • Education
  • Refuse Collection

Those are in no particular order. Those are the necessities. PERIOD. Over the last 5 or so years..maybe longer, firefighters and EMT’s have seen their budgets cut, hacked, and brought down to an all time low.

I don’t care where you are or who you work for, your City/County/Locality should not be cutting the operational funds of any fire and/or EMS department without completely cutting other programs. When I say “CUTTING”, I mean completely gone like they never existed before. Things like economic development, risk management, transportation, technology, fleet management, social services, homeless assistance, general services, planning, neighborhood services, parks and recreation. These departments should be decreased to a skeleton crew and or merged with another department. Other programs should have been deleted way before we got to this point.

Below are stories about Station Closures, Brownouts, Layoffs, and such from the past month to today. Today is important because it is the first day of many jurisdictions fiscal years.

And yet some firefighters have agreed to make up for budget shortfalls out of their own pocket! And to think that there are some assholes out there who just don’t get it. The Administrations, Fire Chiefs, City Councils, County Supervisors, Aldermen,etc. will never understand that we mean business and we are in the business to save lives! We don’t stand up for what we believe in just to hear ourselves talk. Check out these ALL-AMERICANS.

These are just some  examples of closures, brownouts, and layoffs as well as some departments who have given up even more to prove the point that we CANNOT afford anymore cuts for our safety and that of our citizens. Feel free to chime in if you have another City, Link, Story related!